Separate from the note about the workshop, I am surprised to hear about the experience at the Buddhist retreat center -- the experience you share doesn't match the stereotypes many of us would have of such a center.
It has been my experience all my life as well that when you ask certain people questions about why they did something, they take it personally and often even consider it a "battle cry". great post
Because of my language limits (only human language I know is English), the Autistic community I interact with is also English.
They suggest this is a neurotypical vs neurodivergent thing.
When I read from other cultures (especially those indigenous to this continent) I'm told this is an English and/or Western European hyper-competitive thing.
I regularly find more interesting questions than have definitive studies providing answers.
I think all of us are being herded into binaries (typical/divergent) when the reality is that we're just experiencing something, all of us, and none of us are having the same experience....to what degree they can/do vary, would be fascinating to know, but I doubt that's possible...right?
Natural sciences can tell us that there is a wide variety of the human experience, and it is not a natural science that suggests that some are "good" and some are "bad", or that there are simplistic binaries.
Social sciences tell us (especially those doing anthropology of Western cultures) that there are specific worldviews that grew out of the unique history of Western Europe, and were then imposed externally on this continent through ongoing settler-colonialism. Those worldviews then generated hierarchies and imposed a narrow definition of what is "normal". The further you are from these social constructs and social hierarchies that impose a notion of "normal", the more you will be pushed out of society (including systemically made poor, institutionalized, imprisoned, or worse).
If we lived in a society that didn't pathologize difference, then the scientific method could help us explore the full range of the human experience. While I agree that isn't possible under the constraints of THIS specific culture we both live under (including how it is violently exported to other parts of the word), it is not a limitation of the scientific method or of the species that we don't already have a large body of science.
None of us are having the identical experience, but from a social level that is usefully explained by intersectionality. Not being identical doesn't mean we can't recognize patterns and be able to have short-forms to better understand each other. Even with the ideological limits of Western (Western Asian, Western European, and empire/colonial expansion) medicine, there is in the recent century (slower in parts of the Western world) a recognition that biological females and biological males aren't identical.
While gender is not a binary, and more like a spectrum like Autism is (I believe you have seen these colour wheels https://laconciergepsychologist.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/autism-spectrum.jpg ), we live under a culture that hasn't caught up to these basic facts. We have Western governments (and not only the USA) scapegoating people who don't fall into what they claim is the "norm", talking yet again about opening up vast networks of institutions to house us (the real reason that few Autistic people were visible 3+ generations ago).
great reply. Now I'm wondering if I'd want to take a pill that lets you "inhabit another's perspective" for like a day, or a week...let neurodivergent folks swap with neurotypical folks, etc....
Thanks so much for sharing.
Separate from the note about the workshop, I am surprised to hear about the experience at the Buddhist retreat center -- the experience you share doesn't match the stereotypes many of us would have of such a center.
It has been my experience all my life as well that when you ask certain people questions about why they did something, they take it personally and often even consider it a "battle cry". great post
Because of my language limits (only human language I know is English), the Autistic community I interact with is also English.
They suggest this is a neurotypical vs neurodivergent thing.
When I read from other cultures (especially those indigenous to this continent) I'm told this is an English and/or Western European hyper-competitive thing.
I regularly find more interesting questions than have definitive studies providing answers.
I think all of us are being herded into binaries (typical/divergent) when the reality is that we're just experiencing something, all of us, and none of us are having the same experience....to what degree they can/do vary, would be fascinating to know, but I doubt that's possible...right?
Multiple things can be true at once.
Natural sciences can tell us that there is a wide variety of the human experience, and it is not a natural science that suggests that some are "good" and some are "bad", or that there are simplistic binaries.
Social sciences tell us (especially those doing anthropology of Western cultures) that there are specific worldviews that grew out of the unique history of Western Europe, and were then imposed externally on this continent through ongoing settler-colonialism. Those worldviews then generated hierarchies and imposed a narrow definition of what is "normal". The further you are from these social constructs and social hierarchies that impose a notion of "normal", the more you will be pushed out of society (including systemically made poor, institutionalized, imprisoned, or worse).
If we lived in a society that didn't pathologize difference, then the scientific method could help us explore the full range of the human experience. While I agree that isn't possible under the constraints of THIS specific culture we both live under (including how it is violently exported to other parts of the word), it is not a limitation of the scientific method or of the species that we don't already have a large body of science.
None of us are having the identical experience, but from a social level that is usefully explained by intersectionality. Not being identical doesn't mean we can't recognize patterns and be able to have short-forms to better understand each other. Even with the ideological limits of Western (Western Asian, Western European, and empire/colonial expansion) medicine, there is in the recent century (slower in parts of the Western world) a recognition that biological females and biological males aren't identical.
While gender is not a binary, and more like a spectrum like Autism is (I believe you have seen these colour wheels https://laconciergepsychologist.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/autism-spectrum.jpg ), we live under a culture that hasn't caught up to these basic facts. We have Western governments (and not only the USA) scapegoating people who don't fall into what they claim is the "norm", talking yet again about opening up vast networks of institutions to house us (the real reason that few Autistic people were visible 3+ generations ago).
great reply. Now I'm wondering if I'd want to take a pill that lets you "inhabit another's perspective" for like a day, or a week...let neurodivergent folks swap with neurotypical folks, etc....